|
[ Home Page | Message Boards | News | Archive | Ask Cecil | Books | Buy Stuff | FAQs, etc. ]
21-Apr-1978
Dear Cecil:
I remember reading once that the group the Diodes recorded "Red Rubber Ball" to
get back at its composer, Paul Simon, for saying that he hated punk rock. This brings to
mind a question: must a group or singer get any sort of permission before recording
somebody else's song? Or do you just have to pay royalties after the fact? Is asking
permission beforehand just a professional courtesy? --Curly L., Fair Lawn, New Jersey
Dear Curly:
Surprisingly enough, if somebody is determined to do a cover version of your song, it is
well-nigh impossible for you, Joe Composer, to stop them. In general, the right to record
somebody else's song is called a "mechanical license," and usually it's
negotiated in a routine manner between representatives of the copyright holder and the
would-be cover artiste. (Outfits like The Harry Fox Agency in New York generally handle
the publisher's side.) However, in the rare event that negotiations fail, the copyright
laws contain provisions for a type of mechanical license called a "compulsory
license," which, in effect, give anyone the right to record any song he or she wants
to, as long as notice is given to the song's copyright owners within 30 days after the
recording is made and before it is distributed. Compulsory licenses were written into the
copyright laws in 1909 in an attempt to break up a monopoly in the piano-roll industry--an
industry which has since been pretty well broken up, period. So why negotiate at all?
Mainly because the law dictates higher royalty rates and stricter payment schedules for
compulsory licenses than you can obtain with the negotiated kind.
But hey, you say, I've just written a couple of can't-miss tunes that I'm sure will rocket
to the top of the charts as soon as I can get them recorded. Do I now have to worry that
music industry vultures will steal them before I can make my pile? Don't fret, bucky. The
composer's one inalienable right is to decide who will record his song first. Bob Dylan
pulled this one in the notorious case of "Mr. Tambourine Man": the song was
originally set to be issued in a version that Dylan had recorded live at a folk festival,
but Dylan wasn't happy with the results. Unfortunately, his contract with Columbia didn't
give him the right to decide on what material the company released, so Bob didn't seem to
have much of a choice. But then, the Poet of Our Generation remembered his first issue
rights and denied a mechanical license to his own record company. The album was killed.
Meanwhile, the Brothers Four, a once beloved folk group that had fallen on hard times, had
recorded a highly commercial cover version of the song--a guaranteed comeback. But when
Dylan's anticipated first version failed to appear, the group was caught between the
proverbial rock and a hard place, unable to release their dynamite single. It sat in the
vaults until Dylan issued his approved version some months later--but in the meantime, the
Byrds had recorded their cover version, and that was the one that went to the Top of the
Pops. Such are the vagaries of fortune.
For a more detailed discussion of licensing (and lots of other stuff besides), see This
Business of Music, by Sidney Shemel and M. William Krasilovsky. Of this extraordinary
volume even Cecil is in awe.
--CECIL ADAMS
The Straight Dope / Questions or
comments for Cecil Adams to: cecil@chicagoreader.com
Comments regarding this website to: webmaster@straightdope.com
Copyright © 1996-2004 Chicago Reader, Inc. All rights reserved.
No material contained in this site may be republished or reposted without express written
permission.
The Straight Dope is a registered trademark of Chicago Reader, Inc.