Dear Straight Dope:
Let's assume there are eight million people in New York city, and half of this population, four million, takes a dump each day. Let's also assume that each dump consists of a half pound of solids. That means that NYC produces 2 million pounds, or 1,000 tons, of the brown stuff each day. My question is, after this 1,000 tons of poop does down the bowl, where does it go? And dare I ask, what is done with it after it gets there?
SDStaff Una replies:
Finally, a chance to write about toilet topics that isn’t dirty. I’ll try to explain the processes used in modern sewage treatment plants, all the while resisting the temptation to use naughty words.
The processes used for treating sewage vary somewhat from facility to facility, but typically involve multiple steps designed to remove and treat as many solids as possible before returning the water to the environment. Here are the most common techniques:
Primary Screening. Screens remove the largest items in sewage. They generally consist of large bars spaced from 1 to 6 inches apart to catch such items as boards, rags, large plastic items, sanitary pads, and condoms. The screens are regularly cleaned and the collected trash is sent to a landfill.
Secondary Screening. Optionally used, these screens are often fine meshes or moving mesh belts with a much tighter spacing than the primary screens. The finer material they gather is also generally sent to a landfill.
Sedimentation. Sedimentation is the removal of suspended particles by allowing the water to either flow slowly through a large tank or rest for a time in settling basins or ponds. Sometimes a chemical such as alum is added to the water to improve the efficiency of the settling process.
Flotation. Flotation involves injecting air into the water in the form of tiny bubbles. Suspended particles that are too fine to settle will attach to the bubbles and rise to the surface of the water, where they can be skimmed off.
Aerobic Biological Treatment. This process uses bacteria that thrive in oxygen-containing air to break down some of the biological compounds in sewage, producing carbon dioxide and water. Sometimes the waste is aerated (has air injected into it) to assist in this process.
Anaerobic Biological Treatment. Sometimes used instead of or in conjunction with aerobic biological treatment, this process uses bacteria that thrive in the absence of oxygen to break down the biological compounds in sewage. The results of this process are methane, carbon dioxide, and other simple organic compounds. Anaerobic treatment is sometimes used when you want methane, e.g., for use as fuel, but generally the methane must be collected even if there isn’t an end use for it.
After these common treatments, additional filtering, chemical, and biological techniques can be used to give a final “polishing” to the water before it is discharged to the environment, in some cases going as far as adding activated carbon or charcoal. Despite all these steps some organic compounds and bacteria wind up in the environment. However, most of the solid waste is collected as sludge during processing, and this sludge must be disposed of or things will quickly pile up. “Biosolids,” as they are called, were once routinely landfilled or even dumped into the ocean. With the advent of modern environmental regulation this is no longer an option for many municipalities, so other methods of disposal have been developed. For example, biosolids can be used for fertilizer, soil reclamation, and stabilization, and may even be dried out and burned as a solid fuel (typically along with some other higher-energy solid fuel, such as coal).
Let’s look at New York city as a large-scale example. New York residents and businesses discharge about 1.4 billion gallons of waste into the sewers each day, which is treated by 14 sewage treatment plants. While no two treatment plants are exactly the same, they use similar techniques. According to the City of New York Department of Environmental Protection (DEP), the North River treatment plant utilizes large bar screens, settling ponds, aeration and biological treatment, settling tanks, and treatment with sodium hypochlorite. The sludge that remains undergoes further settling, anaerobic digestion by bacteria, and dewatering to turn the sludge into biosolids. DEP figures indicate that your guess of 1,000 tons per day is a little high — in fact New York generates about 1,200 tons of biosolids from all sources (human, food, plant, alligator, and other biological wastes). This lovely fragrant mass was once dumped into the ocean, but since 1988 the city has been prohibited from doing this. As a result, New York has developed a biosolids program that uses the final removed organics for such things as composting, fertilizer, and agricultural lime.
Corbitt, Robert A., Standard Handbook of Environmental Engineering, 1990.
City of New York Department of Environmental Protection, http://www.nyc.gov/html/dep/html/w astewater.html
Wiley Encyclopedia of Energy and the Environment, vol. 2, 1997.
Send questions to Cecil via email@example.com.
STAFF REPORTS ARE WRITTEN BY THE STRAIGHT DOPE SCIENCE ADVISORY BOARD, CECIL'S ONLINE AUXILIARY. THOUGH THE SDSAB DOES ITS BEST, THESE COLUMNS ARE EDITED BY ED ZOTTI, NOT CECIL, SO ACCURACYWISE YOU'D BETTER KEEP YOUR FINGERS CROSSED.